Nantucket Restaurant Review:
What Makes Yummy So Popular

Have you wandered past Yummy on one of your strolls or bike rides along path leading to Surfside Beach and noticed the groups of hungry visitors, waiting for a hamburger or ice cream cone? What is the draw? What is it that makes Yummy so popular?

To an outsider, Yummy looks like a shack, maybe storage for Easyriders Bike Rentals, right next door. But take a closer look, and you’ll see that Yummy is much more. With dozens of offerings made in-house from scratch, the fresh ingredients and homemade, straight-from-the-kitchen flavors are what make Yummy truly special.


Tasty Treats to Start Your Day

Yummy helps their customers wake up by offering fresh-baked goodies made fresh every day. Of course, they have traditional treats such as muffins and carrot cake, as well as cookies, cheesecakes, and brownies, but it’s their banana bread that really stands out. Moist and flavorful, this banana bread is a great way to start your day at the beach, with just the right amount of sweetness.

Not feeling up for baked goodies at breakfast time? Add a little protein with a hearty breakfast sandwich or enjoy a morning wrap filled with scrambled eggs and crisp veggies served on warm, grilled pita bread and topped with a house-made red wine vinaigrette.  Trying to beat the heat? Order a chilled acai bowl to take with you to enjoy on the beach. It will help you stay cool as the sun heats up, with healthy fruits and grains that feel more like an invigorating sweet treat than a good-for-you breakfast.


Delicious Lunch Options

Ready to move on to lunch? Stop by Yummy on your way to the beach for a picnic or refuel after a morning in the sun with one of Yummy’s sandwiches. Yummy offers ever-changing, adventurous daily specials that stay true to their mission to provide fresh, healthy, and delicious meals.

Craving something from the sea? You won’t want to miss Yummy’s ever-popular Lob & Roll. This is a lobster salad, made with unbelievably large, juicy chunks of lobster, mixed with celery,, and mayonnaise, served on a grilled brioche bun. It’s absolute perfection. Want to skip the bun? You can order a lobster salad, with the same delectable components served on a bed of fresh greens: avoid the extra carbs and enjoy the lobster.


The Yummy Burger: Best in Class

One of the most popular items on Yummy’s menu is their burger, and it’s not hard to see why. The Yummy burger is a juicy steak burger topped with a spicy sriracha aioli and a house-made  rich, creamy cheddar sauce. Served on a grilled sweet bun, the Yummy burger is sure to revive you after a long day spent playing in the waves.

Don’t overlook dessert at Yummy, either. In addition to their fresh baked treats, Yummy also offers fruity smoothies to cool you off after a day at the beach. Really looking to indulge? Check out one of Yummy’s thick, made-to-order milkshakes, scooped from one of their rotating varieties of ice cream for a creamy dessert that’s good to the very last sip.

One of the most appealing aspects of Yummy is the grab-and-go nature of the restaurant. It’s as if they know that their food is the perfect match for a long day spent outside, enjoying the beauty of Nantucket and the sand and surf. We couldn’t agree more!

Want to check out more of the amazing restaurants Nantucket has to offer? Download our Complete Nantucket Restaurant Guide.

Nantucket Restaurants

Sold on Nantucket cuisine and ready to make a more permanent move? Let Congdon & Coleman Real Estate help make that dream a reality. Contact us today and let us show you the very best in Nantucket real estate.

Nantucket Rental Homes

About Author

Stephen Maury

Featured Rentals

See All Vacation Rentals